No, it's another one! They're drunk (Matt more than Foggy) and they're playing Truth or Dare. They kiss on a Dare (Matt is fine with it, he said he'd like to try kissing a man). Foggy takes advantage, deciding this is probably the only chance he'll ever get with Matt. He dares him to play "Just the tip". Matt is reluctant but Foggy pushes him to try. Then he doesn’t stop at all, he goes all-in (and doesn't even wear a condom, despite telling Matt that he would). Matt protests, says no, stop, but he's drunk and not very coherent. He doesn't manage to shake Foggy off. Foggy doesn't stop, tells Matt that it's okay, he'll feel good, etc. Gets his hand on Matt's cock to make him come, too. They never really talk about it, after. Foggy has a brief "omg what did I do I need to ask for forgiveness", but then he sees Matt coming out of the shower without saying anything, not even looking angry (he's sad/shocked/numb), and he doesn’t say anything as well. He ends up self-justifying it to himself as a stupid thing they did while drunk. Matt, too, comes to think of it as "really bad sex they had while drunk", poor Foggy was so drunk that he didn't know how to put a condom on... but he stops drinking in sexual situations, once when he's with Frank he checks (touching) that he wore a condom before they do anything. (There's also a scene where Frank gets the story, is furious and goes to threaten Foggy—doesn't kill him because Matt made him promise not to kill anyone if he told him.)
Re: Matt catches Foggy breaking the law
They're drunk (Matt more than Foggy) and they're playing Truth or Dare. They kiss on a Dare (Matt is fine with it, he said he'd like to try kissing a man).
Foggy takes advantage, deciding this is probably the only chance he'll ever get with Matt. He dares him to play "Just the tip". Matt is reluctant but Foggy pushes him to try. Then he doesn’t stop at all, he goes all-in (and doesn't even wear a condom, despite telling Matt that he would). Matt protests, says no, stop, but he's drunk and not very coherent. He doesn't manage to shake Foggy off.
Foggy doesn't stop, tells Matt that it's okay, he'll feel good, etc. Gets his hand on Matt's cock to make him come, too.
They never really talk about it, after. Foggy has a brief "omg what did I do I need to ask for forgiveness", but then he sees Matt coming out of the shower without saying anything, not even looking angry (he's sad/shocked/numb), and he doesn’t say anything as well. He ends up self-justifying it to himself as a stupid thing they did while drunk.
Matt, too, comes to think of it as "really bad sex they had while drunk", poor Foggy was so drunk that he didn't know how to put a condom on... but he stops drinking in sexual situations, once when he's with Frank he checks (touching) that he wore a condom before they do anything. (There's also a scene where Frank gets the story, is furious and goes to threaten Foggy—doesn't kill him because Matt made him promise not to kill anyone if he told him.)