same anon; Mostly I mean that during Waid's run Matt is in a very different place in his life. While he is fundamentally the same person as TV!Matt he's had a longer/different history and some Bad Shit's gone down in his life that he's dealing with. Matt reacts to things differently, and not only that he's got a different context to react to (his reality is very different from the mcu and from our reality). So Matt's going to read as a different person in some ways in comparison to TV!Matt
Not only that but the way Waid, Samnee & the various colourists represent the reality. In comparison to the show, and to previous comics, volumes 3 & 4 are much brighter & features stronger bolder linework separating objects and space. This forces the audience to view the story/reality in a different way (eg; while there is violence & horror in these comics I don't view it as... strongly/darkly as i might in other comics or the tv show???).
So DD v3 & 4 are comicky, but I don't think that that works against them in a way that 'not realistic' might suggest. I would actually say that by the creative team embracing a comic book medium, they have allowed for a more natural representation of the reality that comics!Matt experiences. The thoughts, actions and feelings of the characters and world come across very clearly and understandably. (and for me that's at the crux of a 'realistic' media. Not by how I can compare it to my reality. But how easily I can understand the rules that underpin the fictional reality and the consistency with which concepts and personalities are presented)
Idk.. if this is clear at all... or even relevant to what u were asking/saying. Sorry lol. I just love talking about comics and adaptations im so interested in that.
Re: a query (for science!)
Mostly I mean that during Waid's run Matt is in a very different place in his life. While he is fundamentally the same person as TV!Matt he's had a longer/different history and some Bad Shit's gone down in his life that he's dealing with. Matt reacts to things differently, and not only that he's got a different context to react to (his reality is very different from the mcu and from our reality).
So Matt's going to read as a different person in some ways in comparison to TV!Matt
Not only that but the way Waid, Samnee & the various colourists represent the reality. In comparison to the show, and to previous comics, volumes 3 & 4 are much brighter & features stronger bolder linework separating objects and space. This forces the audience to view the story/reality in a different way (eg; while there is violence & horror in these comics I don't view it as... strongly/darkly as i might in other comics or the tv show???).
So DD v3 & 4 are comicky, but I don't think that that works against them in a way that 'not realistic' might suggest. I would actually say that by the creative team embracing a comic book medium, they have allowed for a more natural representation of the reality that comics!Matt experiences. The thoughts, actions and feelings of the characters and world come across very clearly and understandably. (and for me that's at the crux of a 'realistic' media. Not by how I can compare it to my reality. But how easily I can understand the rules that underpin the fictional reality and the consistency with which concepts and personalities are presented)
Idk.. if this is clear at all... or even relevant to what u were asking/saying. Sorry lol. I just love talking about comics and adaptations im so interested in that.