I'm in the process of re-watching Brotherhood and it occurs to me how much of it Matt would be able to relate to since it deals with things like losing loved ones, disabilities, moving forward no matter what, etc. So maybe in college (or anytime really) Foggy thinks it would be an awesome show to watch with Matt and he hasn't really watched it in a while so he doesn't realize how much the show might impact his emotionally-constipated roommate and he feels more and more like a horrible person as the show goes on. Or something along those lines, I just want Matt watching the show.

+10 for Matt's reactions to some of the more pivotal moments of the show