The first person Matt ever dated shows up at Nelson & Murdock. A really charming guy who grew up at the same orphanage, who tells them stories about how he and Matt were able to be together even though the orphanage had rules against dating. Karen and Foggy are thrilled to meet him...until they notice Matt is super uncomfortable.

It comes out that this guy emotionally abused Matt and coerced him into sex. Matt is embarrassed and still blames himself for it.

Can be gen, Matt/Foggy or Matt/Karen/Foggy. Just fuck me up, please.