Matt keeps coming into work with odd bruises, aches and pains because of his nightly activities. He tells Karen that he's just clumsy. Karen doesn't believe him. She vows to find out what's happening, and also why Matt gets so shifty when someone brings up Daredevil.

Brett KNOWS Foggy Nelson is clumsy, but the idiot keeps coming into the station with scrapes and cuts because he keeps getting caught up in or targeted by people after Daredevil. He tells Brett he just keeps finding himself down the wrong end of town. Brett doesn't believe him. He vows to find out what's happening, and also why Foggy looks so guilty whenever Brett brings up another criminal Daredevil left at the precinct.

Karen and Brett team up to uncover the truth.