I think the problem for me is that Elden didn't really "sell" the line to me? Like, Foggy is usually just so nice to everyone; he didn't have the right inflection when he was telling Marci off. If I were her I'd have laughed in his face for sounding so ridiculous.

(I blame the writers also? It had the same awkward feel as that exposition scene where Foggy had that weird disagreement with Matt in front of the realtor)